Emigration decline could force more drastic measures on immigration


Author(s):  Matt Cavanagh
Published date:  26 May 2011
Source:  New Statesman, Staggers blog

Figures published today by the ONS confirm that net migration continued to rise in the year ending September 2010, up 7 per cent to 242,000 compared to the year ending June 2010. It is time the government admitted that setting a target for net migration makes little sense, and can't be achieved without damaging Britain's economy.

When they set the target in opposition, the Conservatives clearly hadn't planned for emigration falling. Today's figures show emigration of British nationals down by more than 25 per cent since 2008.

long-term-migration 110526

An IPPR report last year explored some of the possible factors behind this neglected aspect of migration trends - including the global recession making traditional destinations like Spain, France, the US, and Dubai less attractive. The tightening of immigration policy may also be having a perverse effect on emigration of non-EU nationals, who may fear that if they go home, they will never be able to come back.

The decline in emigration means the government will have to take even more drastic measures to try to hit their net migration target. They can't control immigration from the EU: today's figures show net migration from Eastern Europe is rising again, up over 50,000 from last year. They have already resorted to massaging the figures, reclassifying tens of thousands of skilled workers on intra-company transfers as no longer counting as 'immigration', and introducing a new 11-month student visa for the same purpose.

They have signalled their intention to clamp down on family immigration, but are likely to find this controversial, and slow to take effect. They are likely to have no alternative but to tighten up even further on students or skilled workers coming from outside the EU - the most valuable kinds of immigration.

A recent IPPR report argued that the proposed reforms to student visas are likely to cause substantial harm to our education sector and economy - and an article in this week's Times Higher Education argues that they are also unfairly discriminatory against private sector education providers.

The cap on skilled foreign workers came into force last month. Even as it starts to bite, there is a risk that a combination of the politically-driven target on net migration, together with (essentially irrelevant) trends in the emigration of British nationals, will require it to be tightened further. This will be bad news for companies wanting to hire skilled foreign workers, and a potentially further dampening effect on economic growth.

Finally, the government will be keeping a nervous eye on the separate issue of asylum: Home Office figures published today show that after many years of decline, asylum claims rose by 11 per cent in the first quarter of 2011 compared with the same period the previous year. They may come under further pressure in the year ahead, as the effects of the Arab Spring are felt. At the same time, removals of failed asylum seekers fell by 9 per cent, despite frequent claims by the Conservatives in opposition that they would do better.