Minding the Markets: Emotional Finance and Financial Instability
We recently hosted a New Era Economics seminar with influential professor David Tuckett, to discuss his new theory termed 'emotional finance' to explain financial market behaviour.
During the seminar, Professor Tuckett described his main findings based on 50 in depth interviews with fund managers, offering a deeper understanding of financial markets and investor behaviour.
Professor Tuckett discussed how markets unleash emotional responses, and he found that human emotions, storytelling and conflicts are at the heart of finance and must be acknowledged as part of their decision making process. He stressed how decisions are made in a state of uncertainty, where information is weaved into a narrative in order to come to certain decisions.
This leads to emotion being a motive in taking risks, where people often find themselves experiencing what he terms ‘divided states’, and ‘group feel’ and creating ‘phantastic objects’. This he says is what was experienced during the financial crisis: individuals perceived financial derivatives as phantastic objects, which led to divided emotional states and group feel, which eventually led to the financial crisis.
David Tuckett is a Fellow of the Institute of Psychoanalysis in London and Professor at University College London. His latest book, Minding the Markets, sets out a new theory – emotional finance – to explain financial market behaviour and the development of bubbles in asset prices in particular. Based on interviews with over 50 fund managers, Professor Tuckett shows how unconscious needs and fears, the influence of groups and the nature of uncertainty are crucial determinants of investment activity.
At this seminar, Professor Tuckett will describe some of the main findings of his research and set out the types of policy that are needed to make financial markets more stable.
Richard Saunders, Chief Executive of the Investment Managers Association (IMA), provided an initial response to Professor Tuckett before the meeting opened up for questions and discussion.
The seminar was chaired by Philip Coggan, the Buttonwood columnist of the Economist.
You may be interested in...
IPPR in the news
Clare McNeil on social care and older people (37min)
BBC Radio 4 Today - 24 Apr 20142m aged over 65 in UK will lack informal care from adult offspring by 2030
The Guardian - 24 Apr 20142m could face old age alone
Daily Mail - 24 Apr 2014Home alone 'nightmare' for 2m OAPs
Daily Mirror - 24 Apr 2014
The idea of "institution building” in future policy
Telegraph - 23 Apr 2014Spencer Thompson on small firms, jobs and sick pay (7min)
BBC Radio Essex - 22 Apr 2014Graeme Cooke on alternatives to payday lenders (45min)
BBC Radio 4 Today - 22 Apr 20141% increase in NI rates could bring in £4bn each year for NHS
The Independent - 22 Apr 2014
One-off payday-loan levy would help fund affordable lending
The Guardian - 21 Apr 2014Church of Scotland welcomes IPPR plan for affordable lenders
The Herald - 21 Apr 2014Call for clampdown on payday lenders
The Times - 21 Apr 2014We must do everything we can to help SMEs carry on the good work
The Independent - 21 Apr 2014
Most of these elderly people have a simple need – not to be on their own
The Observer - 20 Apr 2014One in four small firms plans to hire this year
The Telegraph - 19 Apr 2014Wales says no to Scottish independence
WalesOnline - 19 Apr 2014Ministers are 'not trusted'
Daily Mirror - 14 Apr 2014
A real alternative to loan sharks
Sunday People - 14 Apr 2014Politicians of all stripes suffer sharp fall in trust
Telegraph - 14 Apr 201436% have faith in the parliamentary system
Metro - 14 Apr 2014Labour pledges to introduce Regional Ministers
ITV News - 09 Apr 2014