Energy efficiency: Who pays and who benefits?
Published date: 17 Dec 2012
Download full publication
ECO is a new programme that aims to improve the energy efficiency of homes in Great Britain. Only a limited number of people will be able to benefit from ECO but the cost of the policy will be borne by all energy bill-payers. This report assesses what those costs might be and how the benefits and costs will be distributed.
Coming into force on 1 January 2013, ECO is a programme that will cost suppliers an estimated £13 billion a year. In what marks a radical change from previous supplier obligations, ECO will oblige suppliers to deliver high-cost energy efficiency improvements and improve households that are fuel-poor. Households that are not eligible for support through ECO will have the option of installing measures at no up-front cost through the Green Deal. Unlike the policies it replaces, it explicitly aims to address both carbon emissions and fuel poverty.
If government estimates are accurate then the cost of ECO will replace, roughly pound-for-pound, the costs created by the current policies, worth about £50 a year in the average annual household energy bill. However, analysis of previous policies suggests that the government's estimates could be much too low or too high, which means the cost to consumers could dip to £20 or soar to £116 a year.
There are also concerns that lack of capacity and resources at the local authority level could undermine the scheme's ability to reduce carbon emissions at the lowest cost possible, and that suppliers may find it difficult to identify and engage efficiently and accurately suitable fuel-poor households.
The report's recommendations include:
- An early review to consider which measures are eligible under ECO, including the possibility of extending the policy to include loft and cavity wall insulations.
- Government support for local authority involvement in the form of a £40 million investment in local authority staff and resources.
- Close monitoring of suppliers’ progress towards achieving the fuel poverty target in ECO to identify whether this target is deliverable and cost-effective.
- A pilot of the 'Low-Cost, Low-Efficiency Area' (LILEA) approach to targeting resources at fuel-poor homes, which could be significantly more efficient and cost-effective than current methods.
- Suppliers should be required to submit detailed information on the costs of delivering their ECO obligations, which should be independently verified.
Reg Platt, Senior Research Fellow
Author(s) : Will Straw - 18 Jan 2013
You may be interested in...
IPPR in the news
Mervyn King's housing warning is too little, too late
The Guardian - 21 May 2013Nigel Farage and Alex Salmond trade insults in battle of nationalists
The Guardian - 20 May 2013Local solutions are the key to full employment
New Statesman, Staggers blog - 20 May 2013Exam fail kids are facing jobs woe
The Sun - 15 May 2013
Will Ed Miliband be the Doctor Who of politics?
The Telegraph - 14 May 2013Labour will not be able to meet child poverty targets, says thinktank chief
The Guardian - 13 May 2013Slave-to-work dads ‘being squeezed out of family life,' says MP Jon Cruddas
Manchester Evening News - 13 May 2013Laptop U: Has the future of college moved online?
The New Yorker - 13 May 2013
Ed Cox on 'two-speed Britain'
Observer - 12 May 2013Francis Maude to consider fixed terms for top mandarins
Financial Times (£) - 12 May 2013Childcare reforms in chaos
Daily Mirror - 10 May 2013Sarah Mulley on the Queen's speech (2 mins 55s)
Channel 4 News - 09 May 2013
Queen's Speech 2013: Economist Attacks Immigration Curbs
Huffington Post - 09 May 2013Follow Macmillan and build, build, build
New Statesman - 08 May 2013School inspections deeply toxic, thinktank says
The Guardian - 08 May 2013School League Tables Damaging To Students' Vocational Education, Warns IPPR
Huffington Post - 08 May 2013
A common sense policy to create jobs and combat what ails Britain
The Independent - 07 May 2013250,000 children could suffer due to league table changes
The Telegraph - 07 May 2013Tories braced for big losses in council polls
The Guardian - 03 May 2013Guy Lodge on compulsory voting (47 mins)
BBC Radio 4 PM - 30 Apr 2013