Early years reform: Childminders’ responses to government proposals
This report contributes to the current discussion on childcare reform by considering its impact on the childminding sector. Based on the findings of our survey of childminders, we draw out some suggestions for policymakers on which elements of reform should be maintained and where new ideas are needed.
The overarching message from our research is a positive one: there is a strong desire to boost the quality and status of the profession, driven by the sector. However, this motivation cuts against some specific government proposals, which have been designed with the intention of making childminding more attractive by relaxing or reducing regulation. Childminders reject several elements of reform for fear of their damaging impact on the quality of provision and the perception of their profession.
The majority (57.7 per cent) think more regulation would have a positive impact on the sector. They also reject the suggestion of cutting regulation – 61.8 per cent thought this would have a negative impact. Three-quarters (73.2 per cent) of childminders want minimum requirements in place in order to be allowed to practise (like having or working towar ds a relevant early years qualification).
On the flipside, the large majority (74 per cent) were against the possibility of looking after more children (despite the fact they thought it would boost their earnings) because they felt it might compromise the quality or safety of their care. While 76 per cent believed relaxing ratios would increase their monthly earnings, 93.2 would not reduce the amount they charged to parents per child.
We ask that the government pauses to take stock of its package of childcare reforms. Specifically, we make recommendations on the following alternative or revised reforms:
- Childminder agencies: the government needs respond to concerns that agencies will undermine quality and sustainability, rather than support the sector, before pushing ahead.
- Individual inspections: our research shows a strong preference for individual inspections to continue for all childminders, alongside proposals for targeting inspections on low-performing settings.
- Minimum requirements: all professionals delivering the Early Years Foundation Stage curriculum should have or be working towards a level 3 childcare qualification.
- Ofsted criteria: these should be reformed to ensure they reflect the best developmental practice, with the aim that in future all those delivering the free childcare entitlement will have received at least a ‘Good’ score from Ofsted.
- Professional development: there needs to be more focus on driving (rather than inspecting) quality, through development, peer interaction and training. With the diminishing role of local authorities, there could be space for a sector body, tasked with designing qualifications and accrediting workers as well as mentoring low-performing settings.
Imogen Parker, Research Fellow
You may be interested in...
IPPR in the news
Universal childcare for 3-4 year olds
The Independent - 12 Dec 2013Many have lost faith in the benefits system
The Telegraph - 12 Dec 2013Free childcare could boost economy by £1.5bn
BBC News Online - 12 Dec 2013We need tech-powered public services
Health Service Journal - 12 Dec 2013
State must catch up with modern family dynamics
The Guardian - 11 Dec 2013Place children and elderly at centre stage
The Telegraph - 11 Dec 2013Age of scandal a danger for democracy
Yorkshire Post - 11 Dec 2013We need a strong regional skills policy
The Times (£) - 10 Dec 2013
Science to drive a new British economy
Times Higher Education - 10 Dec 2013Public infrastructure investment just £5 per head in the North East
The Journal - 10 Dec 2013Transport infrastructure spend just £245 per head in the North
The Independent on Sunday - 09 Dec 2013Decentralise housing and transport powers
New Statesman - 09 Dec 2013
North South infrastructure plan divide
The Independent - 06 Dec 2013Tax relief for childcare won't make it cheaper
The Telegraph - 06 Dec 2013We need a green economy
BBC News - 06 Dec 2013Retrain people in their 50s and 60s
The Financial Times (£) - 05 Dec 2013
Transport infrastructure spending far higher in London
The Spectator - 05 Dec 2013Universities should pay a living wage
Times Higher Education - 05 Dec 2013Tax free childcare will not cut childcare costs
Nursery World - 05 Dec 2013Parents thousands of pounds worse of with Govt's tax relief plan
The Telegraph - 04 Dec 2013