Borderland: Assessing the implications of a more autonomous Scotland for the north of England
Published date: 13 Nov 2012
Download full publication
The precise nature of Scotland’s future relationship with the United Kingdom will emerge over the course of the next few years. In this report, we seek to illuminate a neglected aspect of the Scottish debate by assessing the implications of either an independent Scotland or a fiscally stronger Scottish parliament for the north of England.
Voices in the north of England, especially in the political and business communities, have begun to express serious concerns about how they believe greater powers would give Scotland a competitive advantage over the northern economy. In particular, they worry about the consequences for their economies of moves by a fiscally autonomous Scotland to cut taxes in order to encourage investment and business north of the border.
We also briefly explore whether political and constitutional change in Scotland provides an opportunity for the north of England itself to argue for greater autonomy from the Westminster government. Following the recent failure of directly elected mayors – almost a decade on from the failure of elected regional government – the north of England will need to champion a feasible, deliverable form of decentralised government if it is to seize the opportunity presented by developments in Scotland.
This report argues that, in the current climate, Scotland would be constrained in what she could do, particularly in respect of engaging in aggressive tax competition. In particular, the likelihood of Scotland being able to slash corporation tax to 12.5 per cent – as some leading Scottish business figures argue it should – seems remote.
Nonetheless, a fiscally autonomous or independent Scotland will have the potential to muster other capabilities to complement a targeted industrial strategy. And it may well be that this kind of approach should be of greater concern to northern leaders: given the proximity of the North to Scotland, it may be the small things – such as capital allowances or air passenger duty – that prove to be more significant.
It is not for the North to stand in the way of further devolution to the Scottish parliament, or indeed independence, if that’s what the people of Scotland choose. However, northern leaders do need to ensure that there are not detrimental consequences for the North as a result of how the Scottish debate develops:
- First, northern leaders should engage with the negotiations currently taking place about Scotland’s future. As Scotland’s nearest neighbours, it is important that the North joins the debate – especially on the point of what any 'devo-max' option looks like.
- Second, the North should take a leaf out of the Scots’ book when it comes to ambition. Northern leaders should argue that one way to ensure the North does not fall further behind as Scotland becomes more powerful is for it to be given greater control over its own economic future.
Guy Lodge, Associate Director for Politics and Power
In the news
Greater collaboration between the North & Scotland
The Journal - 09 Jan 2014
Scotland could be an ally of Northern England
The Guardian - 22 Aug 2013
Scotland 'must have own currency' after Yes vote
The Herald - 16 Apr 2013
The northern sandwich - stuck in the middle
The Northerner Blog - 19 Nov 2012
Douglas Fraser on Borderland
BBC News Online - 14 Nov 2012
Salmond urges 'northern accord' on high-speed rail
The Herald - 14 Nov 2012
Warning on competition for north of England
Financial Times (£) - 13 Nov 2012
North of England 'needs a Salmond'
The Herald - 13 Nov 2012
North needs a figurehead like Salmond
Yorkshire Post - 13 Nov 2012
You may be interested in...
IPPR in the news
Spencer Thompson on small firms, jobs and sick pay (7min)
BBC Radio Essex - 22 Apr 2014Graeme Cooke on alternatives to payday lenders (45min)
BBC Radio 4 Today - 22 Apr 20141% increase in NI rates could bring in £4bn each year for NHS
The Independent - 22 Apr 2014One-off payday-loan levy would help fund affordable lending
The Guardian - 21 Apr 2014
Church of Scotland welcomes IPPR plan for affordable lenders
The Herald - 21 Apr 2014Call for clampdown on payday lenders
The Times - 21 Apr 2014We must do everything we can to help SMEs carry on the good work
The Independent - 21 Apr 2014Most of these elderly people have a simple need – not to be on their own
The Observer - 20 Apr 2014
One in four small firms plans to hire this year
The Telegraph - 19 Apr 2014Wales says no to Scottish independence
WalesOnline - 19 Apr 2014Ministers are 'not trusted'
Daily Mirror - 14 Apr 2014A real alternative to loan sharks
Sunday People - 14 Apr 2014
Politicians of all stripes suffer sharp fall in trust
Telegraph - 14 Apr 201436% have faith in the parliamentary system
Metro - 14 Apr 2014Labour pledges to introduce Regional Ministers
ITV News - 09 Apr 2014Putting the voice of English regions at the heart of decision-making
The Independent - 09 Apr 2014
Labour's plan to 'bust open' civil service
Guardian - 09 Apr 2014Young electorate showing disenchantment with today’s politics
Financial Times - 08 Apr 2014Labour's plans to boost Whitehall diversity
Evening Standard - 07 Apr 2014Dugher plan to 'bust open' Whitehall to 'working class'
BBC News Website - 07 Apr 2014