Guest workers: Settlement, temporary economic migration and a critique of the government's plans
Settlement is a complex and difficult policy area, demanding close attention to the detail of direct and indirect effects of policy changes and the practicality of compliance or enforcement – as well as questions of fairness and community cohesion.
The government is consulting on a radical policy shift, aimed at reducing dramatically the number of non-EU economic migrants who have the right or opportunity to settle in the UK, which show insufficient evidence of having considered these questions, or of heeding the lessons from similar policies in other countries, past and present.
Under the new proposals, only a few exceptional categories would be invited to stay, in particular the very wealthy. The rest would have to leave after a maximum of five years – regardless of how well they are doing in their job, what contribution they have made, and what roots they have put down in the local community (other than through marriage or civil partnership with a permanent resident).
The proposed approach – in effect, making virtually all non-EU economic migration temporary – is impractical, likely to be damaging in economic and social terms, and unusually for a ‘tough’ immigration policy may even prove unpopular with the public.
This report sets out four key questions the government must answer about its proposed rule changes, and makes a series of recommendations, should the proposals be implemented in their current form. It also provides a progressive framework for managing temporary migration, focused less on compulsory removal than on reinforcing the trend towards temporary migration that is already underway.
Matt Cavanagh, Associate Fellow
In the news
UK may deter most needed migrants
The Financial Times (£) - 21 Nov 2011
Author(s) : Matt Cavanagh - 29 Feb 2012
Author(s) : Matt Cavanagh - 02 Feb 2012
Author(s) : Matt Cavanagh - 03 Nov 2011
You may be interested in...
IPPR in the news
Poor pupil cash 'plugging holes in school budgets'
BBC News Website - 19 Jun 2013Labour promises ‘parent-led’ academies and stricter oversight
Financial Times - 18 Jun 2013Nick Herbert MP: The civil service reform we need
Conservativehome - 18 Jun 2013Let kids apply after their A-level results
The Independent - 18 Jun 2013
PM could appoint Whitehall high-fliers
The Herald - 18 Jun 2013Whitehall reform blueprint
Financial Times - 17 Jun 2013Biggest shake up of how Britain is governed for decades
The Independent - 17 Jun 2013
Ministers ‘must be allowed to choose officials’
The Times (£) - 17 Jun 2013Groundbreaking suggestions on civil service reform
The Guardian - 17 Jun 2013Fathers should get 'use it or lose it' parental leave
Daily Telegraph - 14 Jun 2013Foreign-born men more likely to be in work than British counterparts
The Independent - 14 Jun 2013
Labour takes aim at Murdoch with new call for media ownership cap
New Statesman - 14 Jun 2013Childcare ratio reforms
Huffington Post - 13 Jun 2013Two-year degrees floated by Welsh government
Times Higher Education - 13 Jun 2013Welfare system of ‘shared services’ after independence scorned by academics
The Times (£) - 12 Jun 2013
Immigration chaos 'won't ever be fixed'
Daily Mail - 12 Jun 2013Bring back polytechnics, argues higher education report
BBC News - 11 Jun 2013Labour promises to end Home Office "hostage" of universities
New Statesman - 11 Jun 2013Labour ‘open’ to rekindling targets for overseas student growth
Times Higher Education Supplement - 11 Jun 2013