Ban unpaid internships that last longer than four weeks - IPPR
Research finds number of internships has doubled since 2010 while the number of graduates in high skilled jobs fall into long-term decline
New research from IPPR, the progressive policy think tank, shows internships are on the rise in the UK’s most competitive sectors and are now a ‘must have’ for many top jobs for young people.
The number of internships offered by top graduate recruiters has risen by as much as 50 per cent since 2010. Nearly half of these employers say that candidates without this work experience ‘have little or no chance of receiving a job offer’.
However, the proportion of graduates in high-skilled work is in long-term decline: while 61 per cent of graduates aged 21 to 30 were employed in high-skill occupations in 2008, today only 56 per cent are. An oversupply of graduates effectively means that recruiters can more easily attract graduates to work for free or in low-paid, insecure work. In interviews with young people IPPR’s research found evidence of exploitation, poor working conditions and a lack of meaningful work opportunities.
Some sectors, such as publishing, media and the arts, are proving particularly difficult to access for those without a parent in a managerial or professional occupation. These sectors also have particularly high concentrations of internships. For example, film and television accounts for eight per cent of the jobs market as a whole but 16 per cent of the internships on offer.
While there is a lack of data on unpaid internships given they are often informal and often illegal it has been estimated that 1 in 5 is unpaid, though the proportion varies widely by sector. To prevent internships both paid and unpaid from being a barrier to social mobility, IPPR argues that employers need to offer placements to young people of all backgrounds, not just a privileged few:
- Unpaid internships lasting longer than four weeks should be banned in private companies
- A ‘National Opportunity Programme’ should be introduced, offering residential internships for disadvantaged young people from areas which suffer from a lack of social mobility
- Every student should be able to access a brokered work placement at University
- A new association should be established to give a stronger political voice to interns.
Alongside the report IPPR is launching a new guide to fair internships for employers.
Carys Roberts, Research Fellow IPPR, said:
“There has been an unstoppable rise in internships since the last recession which shows no sign of slowing down. This is creating a structural bottleneck in the graduate labour market, at a time when fewer graduates are in high-skilled work than a decade ago. This means that young people are now more reliant than ever on finding a good internship to get a foot on the graduate jobs ladder.
“Although Theresa May agrees that getting on in today’s Britain is still ‘too often determined by wealth or circumstance’, internships are too often restricted to a privileged few. For internships to help rather than hinder social mobility, universities, employers and government should act together to increase the overall availability of internships and minimise any barriers to take up for those who are disadvantaged.”
Alan Milburn, Chair of the Social Mobility Commission, said:
“This report is welcome. Internships are the new first rung on the professional ladder. They provide access to the best careers, but are too often unpaid and not advertised, making them inaccessible to young people who are locked out of these opportunities because they cannot afford to work for free.
“Restricted access to internships is bad for interns, business, the economy and acts as a major barrier to social mobility. The practice of unpaid and inaccessible internships should end.”
Kieren Walters 07921 403651 [email protected]
- One of the methods for this research was a focus group with former interns, see example responses below:
- - “In my internship I had to get a train and I had to book the train to get there and back. It’s unpaid and my expenses weren’t paid either so it was costing me £15 a day to get there. Then if I was asked to stay late, I felt I couldn’t say no and I would miss my train and have to buy a whole new train ticket. I felt like I couldn’t say, “I really can’t my train is about to leave” so I was stuck because of that whole idea that they would say ‘well you know where the door is’.”
- “I feel like especially with unpaid internships, especially the one I was in, they just wanted someone to do the admin – and this way they didn’t have to pay anyone, they didn’t have to get anyone in permanently. I wasn’t given a contract or any of that, it was just go in, here you go, it’s good for you, you can put it on your CV and if you need a reference, we’ll give you one."
- IPPR aims to influence policy in the present and reinvent progressive politics in the future, and is dedicated to the better country that Britain can be through progressive policy and politics. With nearly 60 staff across four offices throughout the UK, IPPR is Britain’s only national think tank with a truly national presence.
Our independent research is wide ranging, it covers the economy, work, skills, transport, democracy, the environment, education, energy, migration and healthcare among many other areas. ippr.org