Tax bumper pandemic profits to kickstart a fairer and stronger post-crisis economy, says IPPR
- Think tank sets out progressive economic agenda to tackle wealth inequality, secure full employment and shift power in the economy
- Call to learn from ‘Bidenomics’ and invest £47 billion extra across the UK to boost economy and make companies compete for workers, not workers compete for jobs
- Two in five have had real terms pay cut since 2009, analysis reveals, whilst the wealthiest have grown even wealthier during the pandemic
In a major publication ahead of the party conferences of the two main parties, the IPPR think tank has set out a vision for the economic recovery that rebalances power and spreads prosperity across the country.
It calls for £47 billion extra investment this year to help boost the recovery and take the economy to full employment - similar to the Biden administration’s stimulus - so that companies compete for workers rather than workers competing for jobs, driving up earnings and working conditions across the UK.
Measures such as a one-off windfall tax on firms that made excessive pandemic profits, a citizens’ wealth fund that invests in strategic sectors and a stimulus to deliver full employment form part of IPPR’s agenda for structural reform of the UK’s economy.
Merely boosting the current ‘structurally flawed’ economy that channels rewards to a privileged few is not enough, warns the report. It argues that problems of deep unfairness within the economy have worsened during the pandemic, so that as a result:
Even before the pandemic two in five full-time workers had seen a real-terms fall in their income over the previous decade. Now 5.5 million workers are in insecure work, of whom 960,000 are on zero-hours contracts – up from 168,000 in 2010. Some 2.5 million people work in roles that don’t match their skill level.
For wealth owners:
While many feared for their jobs and livelihoods, the richest gained through the rising prices of their property and financial investments. Between June 2020 and June 2021, the average house price rose by £31,000 - equivalent to an average UK salary for an entire year.
Market power and profits are overly concentrated within the top 1 per cent of companies, squeezing out many smaller competitors. Since the pandemic began, just six tech firms have seen their profits triple, adding more than $4 trillion to their combined market value. Pharmaceuticals, healthcare and gaming companies have also gained significantly. But small businesses are more likely to have closed or to have relied on government loans during lockdown; a quarter of the smallest firms that survive report debt repayment costs up by at least 20 per cent.
For nations and regions:
The inability of the UK’s notoriously top-down economic system to respond to local needs was highlighted by tensions between devolved leaders and Whitehall during the pandemic. The poorest areas faced the highest death rates and greatest economic impacts, and are now least able to recover, underscoring stark regional inequalities within England and across the UK.
Prosperity and justice after the pandemic
The report argues that the pandemic must mark an end to constantly growing inequality and the beginning of a new era where opportunity is shared among all people and places, and justice is hard-wired into every policy decision.
IPPR calls for four key power shifts to achieve this: to employees from employers; to companies that work in society’s interest, from those that extract from it; to those locked out of wealth from a system that has locked up wealth; and to the nations, regions and towns of the UK, from Whitehall and Westminster.
IPPR argues that, since the landmark 2018 IPPR Commission on Economic Justice, the public and political consensus on the value of state investment in the economy has shifted. The key question for policymakers now is not whether the state should invest, but how the benefits of that investment should be shared fairly.
To rebalance power in the economy and ensure everyone benefits from economic recovery, IPPR proposes:
- A one-off windfall tax on excess pandemic profits – Firms that made excess profits due to the pandemic must pay their fair share for the recovery, rather than gaining an unfair advantage that reduces their competition.
- A citizens’ wealth fund – Everyone should share in the benefits of growth generated by taxpayer-funded investment. A new fund should be kick-started from the excess profits tax and invested strategically in the economy. Returns on its investments could reduce wealth inequality by granting a ‘universal inheritance’ to all young people.
- UK-wide ‘moon-shot’ missions, like the push to develop the Covid-19 vaccine, backed by government funding and coordination, to spur investment and innovation aimed at achieving net zero and other national challenges.
- A stimulus for full employment – Full employment would mean employers compete for workers, rather than workers competing for jobs, and ensure not just higher pay but greater respect by companies for their workers. The UK should ‘boost it like Biden’ with a stimulus designed to achieve full employment, increasing annual public investment by £47 billion. This should include £30 billion for green projects and £17 billion in social infrastructure, such as health and care.
- A Whitehall to town-hall shift – The UK government should raise investment spending across England to the same level per-head as London through a fair funding formula to replace the current patchwork of local funding pots in England. Citizens, communities and local authorities must be given power to shape how it is used with consequential funding for Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales.
Carys Roberts, IPPR executive director, said:
“The UK suffers from concentrations and imbalances of power that are both a cause of some of our economy’s problems, and a barrier to solving them. The pandemic must mark the end of this era of growing inequality and the beginning of a new one, in which sharing opportunity across people and places is a core objective of economic and social policy.
“As well as measures to support and grow the economy, such as a significant economic stimulus and long-term investment, shifting power must now be a priority. By speaking to people’s concerns and their disempowerment, these power shifts have the potential to build towards a better economy that works for everyone. We call this economic justice.”
George Dibb, head of the IPPR Centre for Economic Justice, said:
“During the pandemic we clapped for key workers, but our report shows that even before Covid-19 two in five of those in work had seen a fall in pay. The UK must target full employment, where instead of workers competing for jobs, employers fight to attract workers.
“Most people do not want to see the economy go back to how it was working before the pandemic. There is a need for change, and our plan to hard-wire the economy for justice will ensure that the benefits of the recovery are shared with everyone.
“While some companies have been closed for the best part of two years, others have made bigger profits than ever before. A windfall tax on excess profits would help prevent those firms gaining an unfair advantage and close the gap with the shops, restaurants and cafes that are the backbone of our economy and have suffered the worst.”
Carys Roberts and George Dibb are available for interview
David Wastell, Head of News and Communications: 07921 403651 [email protected]
Robin Harvey, Digital and Media Officer: 07779 204798 [email protected]
NOTES TO EDITORS
- The IPPR paper, Prosperity and justice after the pandemic by George Dibb, Carsten Jung, Henry Parkes and Shreya Nanda will be published at 0001 on Wednesday 22 September. It will be available for download at: http://www.ippr.org/research/publications/prosperity-and-justice-post-pandemic
- Advance copies of the report are available under embargo on request
- The report will be launched at a webinar featuring a keynote speech from Heather Boushey, economic advisor to President Biden, alongside contributions from Frances O’Grady (TUC), Stephanie Flanders (Bloomberg), Martin McTague (FSB) and IPPR researchers. The event takes place on Wednesday 22 September at 15:00. Sign up to attend the event here.
- The four key shifts:
- Profit margins for the largest and most dominant firms have risen over the past two decades
- The wealthiest 20 per cent of households own two-thirds of total wealth in the UK
- The IPPR Centre for Economic Justice was set up to broaden and deepen the work of the IPPR Commission for Economic Justice, whose landmark final report, Prosperity and justice: a plan for the new economy, was published in September 2018: https://www.ippr.org/research/publications/prosperity-and-justice
IPPR is the UK’s pre-eminent progressive think tank. With more than 40 staff in offices in London, Manchester, Newcastle and Edinburgh, IPPR is Britain’s only national think tank with a truly national presence. www.ippr.org