Think tanks call for bailout conditions for airlines to secure jobs and deliver climate justice
New analysis shows that two major airlines have paid out dividends in excess of £2.6 billion since 2014, while the sector is underpaying corporation tax
Following reports that the UK government is drawing up plans to buy equity stakes in airlines hit by the pandemic, two think tanks, IPPR and Common Wealth, are calling for any bailout to include strong conditions for workers and the public.
The think tanks argue that any bailout of the aviation sector must be contingent on ensuring job security, action on climate change, and a public ownership stake. The think tanks are calling for:
- A permanent public stake to grow public wealth post-crisis
- Adoption of targets by the sector in line with the Paris Agreement, and clear, transparent plans to meet them
- Embedded worker rights and collective bargaining over wages and conditions
- The sector to pay its fair share in taxes
- No lay-offs, with firms taking full advantage of the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme
The call comes in the wake of EasyJet intending to go ahead with its £174 million dividend payout, including £60 million to its founder, despite the company calling for a state bailout.
New analysis from Common Wealth shows how airline companies and airports have prioritised the interests of shareholders over the long-term success of the company or the interests of their workforce, the environment, and wider society. The findings include:
- Easyjet and British Airways have together paid out dividends in excess of £2.6 billion since 2014, with 50 per cent of EasyJet’s pre-tax income allocated to dividends between 2015-2019, on average.
- Over roughly the same period, the holding companies owning Heathrow, Gatwick and Manchester airports have paid out a staggering £4.4 billion in dividends, of which £3.3 billion was paid by Heathrow Airport Holdings alone. In fact, dividend payments by these companies were regularly in excess of 100 per cent of the companies’ net income.
- In addition to these substantial dividend payments, several companies in the UK aviation industry are paying very low effective tax rates. Notably, Wizz Air maintained an effective tax rate averaging just 3.5 per cent between 2015-2019.
Mathew Lawrence, Common Wealth Director, said:
“Extraordinary and difficult times are already producing extraordinary measures. With the Chancellor now considering injecting cash into the airline industry in return for shares, it is vital that public support for the sector comes with conditions attached that work for all of us.
“A bailout should build up a permanent public ownership stake, ensure job security, tackle runaway CEO pay and preferential shareholder treatment, and critically, drive a step-change in the sector's contribution to fighting climate change.
“The crisis demands immediate action to ensure economic security for all. But in doing so, we can take collective steps to build a fairer future economy, one that is just and sustainable by design.”
Luke Murphy, Associate Director for Climate at IPPR, said:
“The Prime Minister has said that this time must be different from when the banks were bailed out in 2008. If that’s to be the case, then public money must be used in the public interest.
“Following this period of unprecedented economic intervention we must not just slip back into business as usual. It is vital that decisions taken today support good jobs and a more sustainable economy, rather than executives on big pay packages.
“If the government is going to bail out the airlines, that must mean taking a long-term equity stake and conditions to keep workers employed, a crackdown on runaway executive pay and dividend payouts, and an overwhelming focus on decarbonisation. It must also mean firms must pay their fair share of tax.”
Robin Harvey, Digital and Media Officer, IPPR: [email protected]
Josh Gabert-Doyon, Common Wealth: 07493 530905, [email protected]
NOTES TO EDITORS
- Common Wealth is an independent progressive think tank that designs ownership models for a democratic and sustainable economy. www.common-wealth.co.uk
- IPPR is the UK’s leading progressive think tank. With more than 40 staff in offices in London, Manchester, Newcastle and Edinburgh, IPPR is Britain’s only national think tank with a truly national presence. www.ippr.org
- The new figures will be published on 22nd March in a Common Wealth briefing paper available at: www.common-wealth.co.uk.
- Dr Joseph Baines (King’s College) and Dr Sandy Hager (City University) contributed to compiling the data and conducting the analysis.
- Figure 1: Average effective tax rate paid by UK companies in aviation industry, 2015-2019
Source: Common Wealth analysis of Orbis database.
Notes: Average effective tax rate is defined here as taxes paid/pretax income, expressed as a percentage, over the period 2015-2019. Note that due to data availability, data for Heathrow Airport Holdings and British Airways Plc reflects the years 2014-2018. As a point of comparison, we have included the average statutory UK Corporation Tax Rate over the same period, as designated by HMRC. British Airways PLC is the UK headquartered subsidiary of International Airways Group.