Fair Shares? Barnett and the politics of public expenditure

Article

The Barnett formula - the Treasury mechanism used to fund the devolved administrations (DAs) in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland - is now the subject of widespread political debate across the four nations of the UK. To help inform these debates this paper evaluates the way the Barnett formula works.

The Barnett formula - the Treasury mechanism used to fund the devolved administrations (DAs) in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland - is now the subject of widespread political debate across the four nations of the UK.

In particular, there are growing concerns that the current disparities in funding across the UK are not fair and that this is creating a tension between the four nations, especially between England and Scotland, which could serve to undermine the Union unless addressed.

To help inform these debates this paper evaluates the way the Barnett formula works and asks:

  • Does Barnett deliver an equitable and fair distribution of spending?
  • Does Barnett provide for efficient and accountable spending?
  • Do the public think the distribution of public spending across the UK is fair? Is Barnett procedurally fair?

Related items

  1. A view of Glasgow, Scotland, from above.

    More than a safety net: The welfare state as springboard to economic success and a better country

    A perceived conflict between social spending and economic dynamism is deeply embedded in both Scottish and UK political discourse.
  2. The Home Office building in London

    Far from settled: The government’s ‘earned settlement’ consultation

    How long should people have to wait until they can permanently settle in the UK? This is the core question underpinning the Home Office’s ‘earned settlement’ policy, currently out for consultation.

  3. Rethinking public sector productivity

    This is the second in a series of IPPR Scotland blogs as part of our project on Employment, Productivity and Reform in the Scottish Public Sector. This project is funded by the Robertson Trust.