Fair Shares? Barnett and the politics of public expenditure

Article

The Barnett formula - the Treasury mechanism used to fund the devolved administrations (DAs) in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland - is now the subject of widespread political debate across the four nations of the UK. To help inform these debates this paper evaluates the way the Barnett formula works.

The Barnett formula - the Treasury mechanism used to fund the devolved administrations (DAs) in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland - is now the subject of widespread political debate across the four nations of the UK.

In particular, there are growing concerns that the current disparities in funding across the UK are not fair and that this is creating a tension between the four nations, especially between England and Scotland, which could serve to undermine the Union unless addressed.

To help inform these debates this paper evaluates the way the Barnett formula works and asks:

  • Does Barnett deliver an equitable and fair distribution of spending?
  • Does Barnett provide for efficient and accountable spending?
  • Do the public think the distribution of public spending across the UK is fair? Is Barnett procedurally fair?

Related items

  1. What would it take to eradicate child poverty in Scotland?

    Delivering on the First Minister’s commitment to ‘eradicate’ child poverty seems a long way off.
  2. A wind farm in the hills to the south of Glasgow, Scotland.

    Apathy and opposition: Understanding the real threats to net zero

    Climate action is under siege from populist and far-right actors. Delivering under that pressure demands fresh confidence and commitment from government. 
  3. A flood warning sign, on a closed country road next to water logged fields in the Avon Valley, Hampshire, England

    Adapt or die: Why progressives need to deal with extreme weather

    The impacts of extreme weather are already directly affecting people and communities across the UK. We lack ways to deal with this.