School Admissions: Fair choice for parents and pupils

Article

We argue in this paper that the current school admissions system is a cause of segregation by social class and ability across our schools system, and is thus likely to hamper efforts to improve all schools. In addition, it is likely to lead to systematic unfairness in terms of whose preferences can be satisfied. We argue that a system of fair choice would take into account the need to achieve a balanced intake in every school.

The school admissions system is one of the most contentious areas of education policy, and secondary school admissions in particular have become a highly controversial political issue.

Parents naturally want their children to go to the best possible school, and the process of choosing and being allocated a place can be extremely stressful. Each year this is reflected in media features about the 'best' schools, and in stories about over-subscribed schools, disappointments, appeals and the various strategies employed by parents to get what they want for their children.

The current system is often described as being based on the principle of parental choice. Yet it is a matter of fact that not all parental choices can be satisfied when popular schools are over-subscribed.

We argue in this paper that the current admissions system is a cause of segregation by social class and ability across our schools system, and is thus likely to hamper efforts to improve all schools. In addition, it is likely to lead to systematic unfairness in terms of whose preferences can be satisfied. We argue that a system of fair choice would take into account the need to achieve a balanced intake in every school.

Related items

  1. A little girl in a red school uniform looks at the camera while another student writes with a pencil next to her

    What comes next: A fairer approach to primary assessment

    England’s primary school accountability and assessment system is not working well for disadvantaged children.
  2. A woman’s hand filling in a postal ballot / voting form.

    A durable majority?: How public opinion on the EU performs under pressure

    A decade on from Brexit, Andy Burnham has signalled that a reassessment of the UK’s relationship with the EU might be around the corner.
  3. Flags of Great Britain and European Union

    New world, new relationship: Our future with Europe

    Britain’s assumptions about its place in the world no longer hold, upturned by Russian aggression, American unreliability and Chinese coercion.