States of Conflict: A case study on state-building in Afghanistan

Article

The efforts to stabilise Afghanistan since the overthrow of the Taliban regime have involved complex endeavours on the part of diverse actors in the international community, and components of Afghan society at both mass and elite levels. Although the internal Afghan contributions, both positive and negative, should not be underestimated, the focus of this case study is primarily on the activities of the wider world. The story is not a happy one, with dedication on the part of some global actors undermined by incompetence and limited attention span on the part of others. If there is a broader lesson from this case, it is that there can be no international 'quick fixes' for severely disrupted states. This lesson also applies as governments contemplate how best to proceed in Afghanistan from this point.

The efforts to stabilise Afghanistan since the overthrow of the Taliban regime have involved complex endeavours on the part of diverse actors in the international community, and components of Afghan society at both mass and elite levels. Although the internal Afghan contributions, both positive and negative, should not be underestimated, the focus of this case study is primarily on the activities of the wider world. The story is not a happy one, with dedication on the part of some global actors undermined by incompetence and limited attention span on the part of others. If there is a broader lesson from this case, it is that there can be no international 'quick fixes' for severely disrupted states. This lesson also applies as governments contemplate how best to proceed in Afghanistan from this point.

Related items

  1. A view of Glasgow, Scotland, from above.

    More than a safety net: The welfare state as springboard to economic success and a better country

    A perceived conflict between social spending and economic dynamism is deeply embedded in both Scottish and UK political discourse.
  2. The Home Office building in London

    Far from settled: The government’s ‘earned settlement’ consultation

    How long should people have to wait until they can permanently settle in the UK? This is the core question underpinning the Home Office’s ‘earned settlement’ policy, currently out for consultation.

  3. Rethinking public sector productivity

    This is the second in a series of IPPR Scotland blogs as part of our project on Employment, Productivity and Reform in the Scottish Public Sector. This project is funded by the Robertson Trust.