The relational state: How recognising the importance of human relationships could revolutionise the role of the state

Article

The purpose of this collection is to introduce and discuss the idea of the 'relational state' - a new intellectual and political perspective on statecraft and the public services.

Sparked by the financial crisis and subsequent recession, the centre-left is locked in a serious debate about the core tenets of its political economy. It is striking, however, just how little discussion there has been in relation to the purpose and role of the state in general - and public services in particular.

The impetus for the 'relational state' is rooted in its critique of the 'new public management' model and, in particular, the dominant statecraft of the last Labour government. However, the nature and depth of this critique varies across the authors in this collection: some argue that its edges need to be smoothed off and its core methods redirected towards different, more relational, goals. Others mount the case for more fundamental change, affecting both the aims and practices of public services and the state. There is also consensus on the need for human relationships to be given greater priority as a goal of policy and in the design and operation of public services, which challenges a strict adherence to egalitarian goals and state-led agency above all others.

There is both shared ground and sharp disagreement among those who are interested in advancing the concept of the relational state. This collection aims to kickstart thinking through two essays from leading political theorists - Geoff Mulgan and Marc Stears - who introduce their distinctive ideas about the relational state, followed by a series of short responses which critique and advance their arguments in a number of different directions.

Section 1: Context

  • Graeme Cooke and Rick Muir - The possibilities and politics of the relational state

Section 2: Vision

  • Geoff Mulgan - Government with the people: the outlines of a relational state
  • Marc Stears - The case for a state that supports relationships, not a relational state

Section 3: Perspectives

  • Nick Pearce - Under pressure: the drivers of a new centre-left statecraft
  • Duncan O'Leary - Sure Start and the dilemmas of relational politics
  • Hilary Cottam - From relational ideas to relational action
  • Axel Heitmueller - Relational reality: citizen-centred healthcare
  • Tess Lanning - Power games: shaping a more democratic relational state
  • Jon Wilson - Set our schools free: a relational approach to education
  • Jon Stokes - The psychology of the relational state
  • Tessa Jowell - The relational state: a revolution in the making

Related items

  1. A mother and child from behind looking out of a window

    Restoring security: Understanding the effects of removing the two-child limit across the UK

    The government’s decision to lift the two-child limit marks one of the most significant changes to the social security system in a decade.
  2. A group of healthcare professionals sitting in a staff common room in a hospital in Newcastle

    Building a healthier, wealthier Britain: Launching the IPPR Centre for Health and Prosperity

    Following the success of our Commission on Health and Prosperity, IPPR is excited to launch the Centre for Health and Prosperity.
  3. The Home Office building in London

    A ‘paradigm shift’ in asylum and immigration policy?

    In 2019, a package of asylum reforms known as the ‘paradigm shift’ was passed by a broad party consensus in the Danish parliament.