Greasing the wheels: Getting our bus and rail markets on the move

Article

This report focuses on the relationship between public and private stakes in rail services, and differences between bus services in London and elsewhere.

Our analysis examines the pros and cons of existing policy for both of these transport markets. While policy for London buses seems to be performing reasonably well, there are challenges facing rail which need addressing, though these pale in comparison to those facing bus markets outside London.

Policy recommendations for rail cover:

  • allowing public sector rail operators to compete for franchises, including as part of a joint venture with private companies
  • handing responsibility for franchising decisions to the Office of Rail Regulation
  • encouraging train operating companies (TOCs) to contribute more towards infrastructure costs and reduce the burden on taxpayers

Recommendations focused on bus services outside London include:

  • giving greater powers and responsibilities to local bodies to shape local bus markets
  • replicating the Transport for London (TfL) model at the city-region and combined authority level
  • greater integration of transport spending and services by health and education providers (such as hospital shuttles and school buses)
  • a new long-term, national transport strategy, to be written and owned by the Department for Transport.

Related items

  1. The Home Office building in London

    A ‘paradigm shift’ in asylum and immigration policy?

    In 2019, a package of asylum reforms known as the ‘paradigm shift’ was passed by a broad party consensus in the Danish parliament.
  2. A wide shot of the debating chamber at the Scottish parliament

    A return north: reflections on IPPR Scotland’s tenth anniversary conference

    There’s nothing like moving away from Scotland to remind you just how Scottish you are. 
  3. Newcastle street view of famous bridge and buildings

    The evolution of devolution: How the English devolution and community empowerment bill can go further

    The government’s early commitment to broadening and deepening devolution in England is very welcome, but the bill must be bold enough to make change that people can see and feel.